Arizona, Land of Contradictions

Arizona is one of the most complicated states I’ve ever visited. In the fall of 2007 I was living with my wife in Tucson. For Thanksgiving we left Tucson and eighty degree weather for some time at the Grand Canyon. That night we slept in a tent on the rim of the Canyon for as long as we could stand it, braving sub-freezing temperatures in sweatpants and long sleeve shirts. Well before sunrise we finally retreated to the car, where in a very environmentally unsound fashion we idled the engine for hours to enjoy the heat and defrost our faces. That’s how I think about Arizona: a land of extremes.

Extreme temperature and terrain shifts are also accompanied by extreme compassion and fury. On the compassion side, there are lots of very dedicated people organizing for immigrant rights and to rescue desperate migrants who are attempting to cross the border–hundreds of whom die each year. We were fortunate enough to spend a day with the Samaritans, one of several groups who hike and drive along the border looking for folks in distress.

There is also just an insane amount of anger at Latino immigrants, which I’ve had the non-pleasure of getting to witness over the years, beginning with my travels with the Minutemen in 2005.

What makes Arizona such a funny place for such immigrant hatred is that almost no one I ever met while in Arizona is actually from Arizona (one of the few exceptions were members of the Tohono O’odham Indian Nation). On Sundays at the local sports bar in Tucson, folks argued over what football games they wanted to watch–but no one really cared about the Cardinals. I wanted to watch the Giants, another guy from San Diego was lobbying for the Chargers, a third woman from Wisconsin hoped to catch the Packers. Arizona is a state of newcomers, and like many newcomers, once they lay claim to the area they jealously guard it as their personal property.

Which perhaps helps explain the noxious new bill awaiting Governor Jan Brewer’s veto or signature. The bill, SB1070, would, among many other awful things, allow all government employees who harbor “reasonable suspicion” that a person is undocumented to demand identification and make it a crime for immigrants to not carry authorization papers.

The bill’s sponsor, Russell Pearce, is a complete idiot, but I was also curious to learn that he was joined by a State Representative from Yuma, Bill Konopnicki. If there is one person who should know the benefits of immigrants to Arizona, it’s Konopnicki. For example, here’s a photo of my lettuce crew:

Every other lettuce crew in Yuma consisted exclusively of Latinos, who all presumably look “reasonably suspicious” because they don’t have the pasty white skin of a Russell Pearce or Bill Konopnicki. That’s really what this bill comes down to: if you look Latino, get ready to be targeted.

So I’d like to recommend that everyone make a phone call or send an email to Governor Brewer and demand that she veto the bill. You can email her through this link:

Also, you can make a phone call directly to the Governor at 602-542-4331 or 1-800-253-0883. And definitely feel free to pass along…



Filed under Uncategorized

3 responses to “Arizona, Land of Contradictions

  1. Norah

    I have sent my letter in. I was embarrassed to say I live in Maricopa County – home of Joe Arpaio but now… I guess I’m embarrassed to live in Az…

  2. n20man

    adios illegals

  3. Mimi

    If these “illegals” want to remain in this country…..become a citizen, and wait in line, like all the other law abiding people that want to become a citizen! I have many friends and family members who live in various areas of AZ, and they have said, “we’re not able to let our kids outside, unattended being that there’s a fear of drug cartels shooting and killing people.” REALLY??? Come on, they come over here, the woman get pregnant…drop an achor baby or two…and then they are allowed to stay! That law that says if your born here, “your a citizen!” That law was created during the time of slavery, for the slave owners to have assurance that they owned their slaves even more. NO…..these people jump the borders….come over drain our systems, whether it be public assitance, social security….and NEVER even paying into the system… ALL the ILLEGALS need to go back to where they came from….and for those of you that say, but, your breaking up families! What part of illegal don’t you understand……and another thing, my great grandparents immigrated here, legally, I might add….had physicals, immunizations, etc. they come over here, spread their diseases, TB is now being suffered by those that have caught it from those illegals, it was erraticated…NOT NOW! And if you want to be here….SPEAK & LEARN the English language… great grandparents came here from Poland, learned the English language….and in this day in age……there are many more avenues to exhaust, then they had in the early 1900’s!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s